Vegan Feta Cheese

Vegan Feta Cheese that actually tastes like feta cheese and crumbles like real feta cheese and is cheap and easy to make! 

Published: Mar 15, 2019 · by Melanie McDonald · This post may contain affiliate links · Read my disclosure policy here·  

What’s creamy, crumbly if you want it to be or spreadable if you don’t, protein-packed, super yum, truly multi-purpose and sent from vegan cheese heaven? 

Um, this Vegan Feta Cheese my friends! 

I’ve worked on vegan cheese recipes on and off for ages and ages but have never been happy enough with any of my efforts to share them.

Until now …

I’ve also tried many recipes available online and have never been blown away. That is except for the very talented Full Of Plants and his vegan cheese recipes, particularly the Vegan Aged Camembert Cheese. Amazing is all I can say, but a little too faffy to be making on the regular, and have you seen the price of vegan probiotic capsules and penicillin? 

I totally respect people who get all science-y and make real vegan cheese by growing cultures and all that but it’s not for me.  I just want to throw everything in a food processor and be done with it. 

Are you guys with me? 

And what’s with all of the vegan tofu feta cheese recipes that are literally just cubes of tofu marinaded in oil? You might get something that looks kind of like feta to throw in your salads, but the flavour and the texture is nothing like real crumbly feta cheese. 

You know me. If it’s not really like the non-vegan version, then it’s not making it to the blog. I’m all about authentic tasting vegan dairy alternatives like my Vegan Butter. 

So I made Vegan Feta Cheese for lazy people, that is made with tofu, but actually tastes like real feta cheese and crumbles like real feta cheese and doesn’t include any hard to find ingredients or cost a small fortune to make.

Heck, if you’re feeling extra lazy (hands up me on at least 6 out of 7 days a week), you can skip the baking step and make it into a spreadable vegan cheese with all the flavour of feta.

In its soft state, it is amazing in my Vegan Spanakopita, or spread on crackers or even melted into pasta. 

Tofu really is magic stuff. It is so transformed in this recipe that you would never know it’s actually tofu and I love that. Hurrah for fantastic vegan tofu recipes! 

WHAT IS FETA CHEESE?

Feta cheese is one of Greece’s most popular cheeses. It is made from either sheep or goat’s milk, or a combination of the two, and it is brined, giving it that unique tangy, rich and salty flavour.

Feta is quite firm to the touch, but it crumbles when cut and has a creamy, but slightly grainy mouth feel. It is best known as the cheese used in Greek salads, spanakopita and tyropita. 

WHAT DO YOU NEED TO MAKE VEGAN FETA CHEESE?

This vegan cheese recipe has pretty basic, store cupboard ingredients. There’s nothing fancy. 

You will be needing :

• extra firm tofu
• refined coconut oil
• nutritional yeast
• lemon juice
• apple cider vinegar
• salt
• nutritional yeast
• onion powder
• garlic powder
• dried dill

The only piece of equipment you will need to make this recipe is a food processor. I use this one and love it:

Please note that I recommend using a food processor rather than a blender for this recipe. Even a high powered blender will struggle once the coconut oil comes into contact with the cold tofu and everything sets. It will more than likely just seize up and the blades won’t turn. A food processor is a way better tool for the job and will save you the hassle of starting it in the blender and then having to transfer it all to your food processor.  

WHY REFINED COCONUT OIL? CAN’T I JUST USE VIRGIN/UNREFINED?

I know I will get questions about the refined coconut oil, just like I do with my vegan butter recipe, so I am going to pre-empt them now.

For this recipe, you must use refined coconut oil. You cannot use virgin or unrefined coconut oil. If you are worried about the refining process, there are plenty of brands out there that refine their coconut oil with steam only and do not use chemicals.  Nutiva is one of them and is the brand I tend to use. 

HOW TO MAKE VEGAN FETA CHEESE

SEE MY VIDEO FOR A VISUAL GUIDE. FOR INGREDIENTS & FULL INSTRUCTIONS PLEASE SEE THE RECIPE CARD AT THE END OF THIS POST

Vegan Feta Cheese is super simple to make.

Please take note of the different directions depending on whether you want smooth and creamy results, or firm and crumbly results. 

Add all of the ingredients to a food processor.

Process until smooth but with a little graininess for that authentic feta texture. 

Now comes the part where you have to make a choice. 

You can eat it as it straight out of the food processor. It is so good spread on all the things!

Or, you can spoon it into a lined container, pack it in well, then refrigerate until it has set, then turn out and serve. That way it will have a slightly firmer cream cheese texture, but will get softer as it comes to room temperature. 

Or, the best way …You can spoon it into a baking parchment lined oven proof container, set then bake as directed in the recipe card below.

Then allow to chill completely for at least 4 to 5 hours. That will yield the perfect, authentic feta texture.

Perfect for cubing:

Or crumbling:

It might take a bit of waiting around while making, but the hands on time is really minimal and it really is so worth it! 

I struggled a little with the colour of the baked feta at first. I know traditional feta isn’t usually golden around the edges. I tried other methods of cooking it to reduce the colouration, but, I loved the taste of the slightly crusty golden bits so much, that I decided they should stay. I hope you love them too. If you would prefer them gone so that your feta looks perfectly white, it’s really easy to shave the golden bits off with a sharp knife. Be sure to eat the shaved off bits as you go though! 

HOW TO SERVE VEGAN FETA CHEESE

This Vegan Feta is a really versatile cheese, especially as it can be made in two ways: soft and spreadable or firm and crumbly. 

Serve your vegan feta cheese: 

• With bread or crackers
• With olives
• In salads
• As part of an antipasto platter
• Drizzled with olive oil and sprinkled with oregano
• Crumbled or cubed in salads
• Crumbled on tacos
• On pizza ( the soft unbaked version of this cheese melts beautifully when baked)
• With pasta. (the soft version of this cheese melts into hot pasta so well and the baked, firm version is amazing crumbled or cubed into pasta dishes or pasta salads)
• With potatoes. Try it on a baked potato or melted into mashed potato

HOW TO STORE VEGAN FETA CHEESE

The soft unbaked version of the Vegan Feta Cheese will keep, in a sealed container in the fridge for 5 to 7 days. 

The baked, firmer version of this Vegan Feta Cheese, will keep in a sealed container in the fridge also for about 5 to 7 days. 

You can cube the firmer, baked version, pop it into a jar and cover with olive oil and some herbs and keep that in the fridge for up to 7 days. 

The baked version of this Vegan Feta Cheese freezes very well. Cube it up and put in a sealed container and freeze for up to 3 months. The cubes will defrost in about 30 minutes so you don’t need to wait long for them, and if you are making something like a vegan feta salad for your packed lunch, you can throw in the feta cubes while they are still frozen. Freezing makes the cheese a little drier and crumblier but it still holds together well and tastes great. 

This Vegan Feta Cheese recipe is:

• cheesy
• tangy
• salty
• creamy
• crumbly or soft and spreadable …. your choice
• gluten-free
• versatile
• meltable
• snackable
• budget friendly
• super easy
• packed with protein
• nut-free
• and is quite honestly, the best dairy-free feta cheese that I have tried. 

So if you’re looking for a convenient, cheap, no fuss vegan substitute for feta cheese, that as an added bonus just happens to be loaded up with vegan protein, low carb and completely nut-free, you know what? I got you. This is your vegan feta recipe.

When you’re craving a crumbly vegan cheese that’s tangy, salty, cheesy (or tangy, salty and spreadable), knocks dairy out of the park and tastes like dreams have come true, the search stops right here with this feta recipe!

And please, do not miss my recommendation for melting the soft version of this feta into freshly cooked and drained pasta. Dollop it in, stir it up and it will coat the pasta beautifully. Add some freshly ground black pepper and a pinch of chili flakes and you’ve got a super special dinner in no time at all! And you really must try it on pizza too! 

For more vegan dairy substitutes check out these great options:

1. Easy Vegan Butter
2. Vegan Cream Cheese
3. Oat Milk
4. Nut-Free Vegan Cheese Sauce
5. Cashew milk

If you love this recipe, please do checkout my cookbook, and subscribe to my email list for a fabulous FREE eCookbook featuring my top 10 recipes. Being on the list means you’ll be kept in the loop on all things new and exciting too! 

Print Recipe

4.5 from 16 votes

Vegan Feta Cheese

Vegan Feta Cheese that actually tastes like feta cheese and crumbles like real feta cheese and is cheap and easy to make! 

Prep Time15 mins

Cook Time35 mins

Refrigeration time4 hrs

Total Time55 mins

Course: Appetizer, Lunch, Snack

Cuisine: gluten-free, vegan

Servings: 425 grams of cheese

Calories: 191kcal

Author: Melanie McDonald

Ingredients

• 350 g / 12 oz extra firm tofu , no need to press
• ½ cup / 120 ml melted refined coconut oil (measured after melting) , it MUST be refined and not unrefined or virgin
• 45 ml / 3 tablespoons freshly squeezed lemon juice
• 30 ml / 2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
• 1 tablespoon nutritional yeast
• 1 teaspoon onion powder
• ½ teaspoon garlic powder
• ¼ teaspoon dried dill , please note the finished feta does not taste of dill at all - Strangely, it helps the feta flavour so please don't omit it.
• 1½ - 2 teaspoons salt , or to taste

Instructions

• Add all of the ingredients to a food processor (this recipe does not work well in a blender, even a high powered one), starting off with only half of the salt. Blend it all up until smooth then taste and add more salt as needed. Blend to incorporate it after each addition. Remember that this is feta so it should have quite a salty edge. I like to use a full 2 teaspoons in mine. 

FOR SOFT SPREADABLE VEGAN FETA (THAT WILL ALSO MELT)

• Serve straight from the blender, or pack into a container and refrigerate for a few hours for a firmer, spreadable cheese. If you want to be able to turn it out for use on a cheese board, line the container with cling-wrap so that you can easily remove it once it's set. 

FOR FIRM, CUBE-ABLE & CRUMBLY VEGAN FETA

• Line an oven proof pan/dish with baking parchment. A square or rectangular shaped pan/dish is best if you want to be able to cut perfect cubes once it's ready. A loaf pan will work well. It doesn't matter if the cheese doesn't fill the container. You just need the cheese to be between 1 and 2 inches deep once it's in there. 
• Spoon the cheese from the food processor into the oven proof dish and push it down well and evenly. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours (or overnight is fine). This step is important. If you don't refrigerate before baking, the coconut oil can separate a little on the bottom while cooking. 
• Preheat oven to 400°F (200 °C) and once at temperature, remove the cheese from the fridge and bake uncovered for 35 minutes. 
• Remove from the oven. It will be puffy, a bit soft and bubbly but will set again as it cools. Allow to cool, then refrigerate for at least 4 hours (or overnight) before cubing or crumbling. 

Video

Notes

For an authentic feta flavour, it is very important to not alter the ingredients or their quantities at all (except for the salt). Every one plays an important role and the recipe will not be at its best if you change them. 

STORAGE & FREEZING

The baked Vegan Feta Cheese can be frozen for up to 3 months in an airtight container. I like to cube mine first. The frozen cubes only take about 20 minute to defrost so they can be taken out as needed. If you are making something like a salad for a packed lunch or pot luck, you can add the cubes to it while still frozen. 
I do not recommend freezing the soft, spreadable feta cheese. 

Vegan Feta Cheese will keep, in a sealed container in the fridge for 5 to 7 days. 

The firmer, baked version, can be cubed and covered with olive oil and some herbs and kept in the fridge for up to 7 days. 

TIP

When I make this recipe, I like to divide my cheese mixture in half and make one of each kind of cheese. Soft and spreadable and firm and crumbly. I use 2 mini loaf pans and split the cheese mixture between them, then follow the directions above for preparing each one.